What is the nicest and safest Caribbean island?
Anguilla was also ranked as one of the top islands globally, and the highest ranked in the Caribbean, within Travel + Leisure’s 2025 World’s Best Awards. Following Anguilla, Barbados, St. Barthélemy, Martinique, and the Cayman Islands ranked in the top five as the safest countries in the Caribbean. Aruba is generally a safe destination for travelers, but like any other place, it’s not without its risks. What not to do in Aruba is to venture into unfamiliar or potentially dangerous areas, especially after dark. It’s important to avoid poorly lit streets, secluded beaches, and areas known for petty crime.According to the 2025 Caribbean Island Safety Index, created by Always All Inclusive, the island of Aruba is the safest Caribbean travel option this summer. This island is a dream for worry-free travel, even during hurricane season,” the ranking reads. It’s especially great for families and solo travelers.
What’s the safest Caribbean island for Americans?
According to these profiles, the safest islands to visit in the Caribbean include Saint Barthélemy, Anguilla, and Aruba as top-tier destinations with exceptional security. Second-tier safe islands include the Cayman Islands, Barbados, and Turks and Caicos with strong safety foundations. Aruba ranked at the top of the list namely because of its low crime rate and focus on tourism safety. Surrounding Caribbean islands such as the Dominican Republic, Jamaica and Haiti, have U. S.Aruba is safe compared to many Caribbean destinations with a low violent crime rate (assault, armed robbery) of ~7. The local government works hard to protect residents and tourists. Police patrol major resort areas every day. You will see officers on foot near hotels, beaches, and shopping centers.